Skip to main
Fingers Crossed
  • PopularCurrent Category
  • Mains
  • Sides
  • Combos
  • Dessert
  • Beverages

Fingers Crossed Menu

619 Lexington Ave, New York, NY

619 Lexington Ave, New York, NY

·

  • PopularCurrent Category
  • Mains
  • Sides
  • Combos
  • Dessert
  • Beverages

Popular

  • Empanadas (3 pc).

    Empanadas (3 pc)

    $9.50+

  • Takoyaki (6 pc).

    Takoyaki (6 pc)

    $12.00+

  • Hands full — 3–4 people.

    Hands full — 3–4 people

    $42.00+

  • Tequeños (8 pc).

    Tequeños (8 pc)

    $11.00+

  • Make it yourself!.

    Make it yourself!

    $30.00+

  • Buffalo wings (6 pc).

    Buffalo wings (6 pc)

    $14.00+

  • Mozzarella sticks (5 pc).

    Mozzarella sticks (5 pc)

    $10.50+

  • Lucky bite — 1–2 people.

    Lucky bite — 1–2 people

    $23.00+


Mains

Buffalo wings (6 pc)

Crispy wings, tossed hot in classic buffalo. Zero forks required — bring napkins instead.

$14.00+

Buffalo wings (6 pc).

Empanadas (3 pc)

Golden, hand-folded pockets packed with seasoned beef and sealed in a flaky crust. Portable, no plate required, and gone in about four bites — which is exactly the point.

$9.50+

Empanadas (3 pc).

Takoyaki (6 pc)

Crispy-edged, molten in the middle, and stuffed with octopus.

$12.00+

Takoyaki (6 pc).

Falafel (5 pc, with a side of pita)

Crispy on the outside, herb-packed and tender in the middle. Served with warm pita for scooping — because even our vegetarian option follows the zero-fork rule.

$10.50+

Falafel (5 pc, with a side of pita).

Sides

Loaded potato skins (4 pc, bacon, cheddar, scallion)

Crispy skins loaded with melted cheddar, bacon, and scallion. Sour cream on the side for dunking — hands only, obviously.

$11.50+

Loaded potato skins (4 pc, bacon, cheddar, scallion).

Mozzarella sticks (5 pc)

Breaded, fried, and stuffed with cheese that pulls all the way to your mouth if you're patient enough to wait ten seconds after they hit the table. Marinara on the side, in case you need something to dip into instead of just eating with your hands.

$10.50+

Mozzarella sticks (5 pc).

Tequeños (8 pc)

Crisp on the outside, molten cheese on the inside — a Venezuelan classic that turns "just one more" into a group decision. Best eaten while they're still pulling that first cheese-stretch.

$11.00+

Tequeños (8 pc).

Combos

Built for the table, not the tray. Every combo is a mix of entrées, sides, and a dessert finish, sized to scale from a couch night for two to a whole table with nobody holding back. No forks, no fuss — just hands, napkins, and food built to be passed around. Pick your size and let the platter do the rest.

Make it yourself!

You can pick 10 items from the menu : -Wings -Falafel -Empanadas -Tequenos -Takoyaki -Loaded potato skins -Mozzarella Sticks

$30.00+

Make it yourself!.

Lucky bite — 1–2 people

Mains: 6 Buffalo wings Side: 8 Tequeños

$23.00+

Lucky bite — 1–2 people.

Hands full — 3–4 people

Mains: 6 Buffalo wings, 3 Empanadas Sides: 8 Tequeños, 5 Mozzarella sticks

$42.00+

Hands full — 3–4 people.

Fingers crossed platter — 5–7 people

Mains: 12 Buffalo wings, 6 Empanadas, 6 Takoyaki Sides: 16 Tequeños, 5 Mozzarella sticks, 4 Loaded potato skins Dessert: 5 Churros

$74.00+

Fingers crossed platter — 5–7 people.

Whole table — 8–10 people

Mains: 18 Buffalo wings, 9 Empanadas, 10 Falafel (with pita), 12 Takoyaki Sides: 24 Tequeños, 10 Mozzarella sticks, 8 Loaded potato skins Dessert: 10 Churros

$115.00+

Whole table — 8–10 people.

Dessert

Churros (5 pc, with dulce de leche)

Fried to order, rolled in cinnamon sugar, still warm when the dulce de leche hits. The one item on the menu you're allowed to lick your fingers for.

$9.50

Churros (5 pc, with dulce de leche).

Beverages

Coca-Cola

$3.50

Coca-Cola.

Coca-Cola Zero

$3.50

Coca-Cola Zero.

Water

$3.50

Water.
NY

Our Story

Events

Catering

We're Hiring

Terms of serviceAccessibility

Fingers Crossed 2026 All Rights Reserved

Powered by Owner